Can I Reheat Pizza? Tips on Which Method is Best

One of America’s favorite comfort foods is pizza. Whether you prefer a plain cheese, meat lovers, or vegetarian special, you can easily have dinner for yourself, family, or friends without turning your kitchen into a disaster by grabbing a pie from your local pizzeria. 

Please note: Some of the links in my posts are affiliate links. I get commissions for purchases made through those links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases when you buy something from those links.

When it comes to pizza, though, there’s nearly always some left over. You may have tried to reheat pizza before, only to end up with a soggy mess, leaving you with two options – throw the pizza away or eat it cold. But those aren’t your only choices! 

There are six common ways that you can reheat pizza and we’ll explore these various options for reheating pizza. By the time you’re done reading this article, you’ll have all your pizza reheating questions answered, and you’ll be able to determine what reheating method works best for you after your next pizza night! 

Can You Reheat Pizza?  

Just like you can reheat your chicken dinner from last night, you can also reheat pizza. Nearly any food that has been frozen or refrigerated can be reheated; you just need to follow the proper steps.  

Can You Reheat Pizza

Reheating pizza leftovers is an easy way to have a second dinner and to experience all the cheesy deliciousness you enjoyed when you first had it. If you aren’t sure how to best reheat your pizza, then you’re in luck. We’ve outlined the many ways below so you can choose an option that is best for you. 

Should You Reheat Pizza?  

The short answer is yes! Just because you couldn’t finish a pizza in one sitting doesn’t mean any leftovers need to go to waste.   

There are countless tips for reheating pizza, and each one will give you a pizza slice that is almost as good as it was when you first brought it home. 

To get the best result, you’ll want to pay attention to what ingredients are on top of your pizza and whether or not it was left out too long. Some people love clam, shrimp, chicken, and other meat on their pizza, so it’s always a great rule of thumb to do some research if you had any unusual toppings on your pie. 

Now that you know you can, and should, reheat your pizza, let’s check out some ways to make your pizza tasty again using a variety of different methods. 

How to Reheat Pizza in the Oven 

If time allows, people often prefer to reheat leftover pizza in an oven. Reheating it this way ensures your pizza will maintain the crispiness you loved when you first had it. 

Reheating pizza in an oven is easy – all you have to do to get started is preheat your oven to 425 degrees Fahrenheit. From there, you’ll want to place the leftover pizza, or just whatever slices you want, directly on the rack of your choice.  

The lower the rack, the crispier your crust will be. Regardless of what rack you choose for reheating pizza in an oven, avoid the top rack because that can cause your cheese to burn. Finally, bake the pizza for 9 to 10 minutes and enjoy! 

How to Reheat Pizza in the Microwave 

When it comes to reheating pizza in a microwave, what often deters people from reheating this way is that they are left with soggy pizza – and who wants that? The good news is that there is a way to reheat your leftover pizza in your microwave without this happening. 

To ensure your pizza remains crispy, place a glass cup of water in the microwave alongside your slice of pizza and microwave it on high for 30 to 45 seconds. The result will be pizza almost as crispy as it was the night before. 

How to Reheat Pizza in an Air Fryer 

Using an air fryer is a quick option that can allow you to reheat a slice or two of pizza. This is also a great choice if you have any deep-fried ingredients on your pizza. 

To avoid any mess from melted cheese, place a piece of aluminum foil or perforated parchment paper on the bottom of the air fryer basket. Once you do that, you can put your slice or two of pizza in the air fryer for 3 to 6 minutes at 360 degrees Fahrenheit.  

After 3 minutes check the pizza to see if it has reached your desired reheating and put it back in if it needs longer.  

How to Reheat Pizza on a Grill 

Reheating pizza on a grill follows a similar format to reheating pizza in an oven. What makes reheating pizza on a grill so great, though, is that you can do this while you are outside enjoying a beautiful summer night with your family.  

If it’s grilling season, don’t overlook this option for reheating your pizza. 

To get started, preheat your grill to 425 degrees Fahrenheit. Once preheated, place your pizza, or any slices you want, directly on the grill grates and close the lid.  

Let the pizza grill for about 7 minutes uninterrupted, until the cheese begins to bubble. Remove it from the grill and dive in. 

How to Reheat Pizza in a Toaster Oven 

While not everyone has a toaster oven, if you happen to have one handy, you’ll find that reheating pizza in a toaster oven is the perfect cross between the ease of a microwave and the result an oven will get you. 

How to Reheat Pizza in a Toaster Oven

Unlike if you were to use your oven or grill, preheat your toaster oven to just 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Once your toaster oven reaches that temperature, simply put in your desired number of pizza slices, close the door, and reheat the pizza for 10 to 15 minutes.  

You’ll know the pizza is ready to come out once the cheese begins to melt again. 

How to Reheat Pizza in a Pan on the Stove 

As you’ve likely gathered already, there are countless options for you to reheat your pizza. One way you may not have thought of before is reheating your pizza on the stove. 

Just like you would reheat other food on the stove, grab a nonstick skillet and begin heating it over medium-low heat. From there, place your slice in the pan (or two slices depending on the size of your pan).  

Don’t move your pizza slices for 2 minutes until the bottom of the pizza slice is crispy. Once the bottom is crispy, add two drops of water to the bottom of the pan, ensuring the water is away from the slice. 

Cover the skillet for 1 minute until the cheese is melted. Remove the slices from the pan and enjoy! 

WINNER – The Best Way to Reheat Pizza is by Using an Oven 

The best way to reheat pizza is by using an oven. An oven is a kitchen staple and if you have 10 minutes or so, you can reheat an entire pizza, so you don’t have to reheat slices in batches. This is our favorite way to reheat pizza, guaranteeing the same crispiness and cheesiness as when you first picked it up. 

We’d love to hear from you as you reheat your pizza at home. Please share your favorite tips for reheating pizza in our comments below! 

Leave a Comment