Can I Reheat Buffalo Wild Wings? Tips on Which Method Is Best

When you go out for Buffalo Wild Wings, you order extra. It’s just what you do. You can’t help yourself. You’ll always want more.  

Please note: Some of the links in my posts are affiliate links. I get commissions for purchases made through those links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases when you buy something from those links.

Which means you’ll end up with leftovers.  

So now you’re wondering, “Can I reheat Buffalo Wild Wings?” 

And once you’ve answered that question, you’ll need to know the best ways to do it. Because the last thing you want is to ruin those amazing leftover wings.  

Can You Reheat Buffalo Wild Wings? 

Let’s get this one out of the way first.  

Can You Reheat Buffalo Wild Wings?

Can you reheat Buffalo Wild Wings? Of course! 

You will be hard-pressed to find a food that has been refrigerated or frozen that you can’t reheat.  

The real issue is how to do it right.  

In general, foods that have been baked or grilled are better off reheated in the oven or back on the grill. Foods that have been breaded or fried are best reheated in the oven or in an air fryer.  

And, of course, there are multiple options that can serve you if you are limited in your appliances.  

When it comes to Buffalo Wild Wings, you are probably going to be better off reheating them with either an air fryer or in the oven. 

But it is certainly worth exploring our options.  

Should You Reheat Buffalo Wild Wings? 

Before we get into how to reheat Buffalo Wild Wings, let’s talk about whether or not you should.  

With issues around foodborne illness and safe food handling, you should always do your own research when it comes to reheating food.  

Since Buffalo Wild Wings are chicken, you will want to take every precaution necessary to be sure you reheat them according to reliable sources.  

To get you started, I have linked this article from the BBC on what you need to know about reheating takeaways.   

How to Reheat Buffalo Wild Wings in the Oven 

Since the oven is likely your best approach, let’s start there.  

Reheating Buffalo Wild Wings in the oven is easy.  

  1. Preheat your oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit.  
  2. Place your wings on a baking sheet lined with aluminum foil.  
  3. Make sure your wings are in a single layer and spaced evenly apart, so they are not touching each other. This process will allow them to fully heat through.  
  4. Reheat your wings for 15-20 minutes, checking on them around the 15-minute mark.  
  5. Stick your thermometer into the meatiest part of the wing and test for 165 degrees Fahrenheit.  
  6. Once you’ve hit that mark, remove and enjoy! 

How to Reheat Buffalo Wild Wings in the Microwave 

The trick to reheating Buffalo Wild Wings in the microwave is not to overheat them and dry them out. Follow these steps for the best results: 

  1. Line a microwave-safe plate with a damp paper towel.  
  2. Place your wings on the plate and cover them with another damp paper towel.  
  3. Reheat your wings on full power for 3 minutes then remove them to test for 165 degrees Fahrenheit.  

You want them heated through to a safe temperature but not overheated. You can always return them to the microwave for a minute at a time until they reach the safe temp.  

How to Reheat Buffalo Wild Wings in an Air Fryer 

Reheating Buffalo Wild Wings in an air fryer is only tricky in terms of space. 

If you have a lot of these bulky snacks, you will want to reheat them in increments so you can be sure they heat all the way through.  

  1. Preheat your air fryer to 350 degrees Fahrenheit.  
  2. Place your wings in the basket, spaced out evenly.  
  3. Spray your wings with a spray oil to keep them moist.  
  4. Reheat your wings for 10 minutes, checking at the halfway mark to be sure the temperature is rising.  
  5. If for any reason your wings have not heated through fully after 10 minutes, you can reheat for another 2 minutes at a time until they reach the correct temperature.  

How to Reheat Buffalo Wild Wings on a Grill 

Should you fire up your grill to reheat your wings? 

No. Of course not. There are much better, easier ways to get the job done.  

But if you already have your grill fired up, reheating Buffalo Wild Wings on a grill can lend an earthy, smoky flavor to the wings that is to die for.  

  1. Set your grill to low flame.  
  2. Wrap each wing individually in aluminum foil.  
  3. Place the wings on the grill and close the lid.  
  4. Turn the wings after 4 minutes and cook for another 4 minutes with the lid closed.  
  5. Check your temperature for 165 degrees Fahrenheit and enjoy! 

How to Reheat Buffalo Wild Wings in a Toaster Oven 

If the toaster oven is what you have to work with, we can make it work for those wings. Just follow these directions: 

  1. Preheat your toaster oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. 
  2. Lay your wings on a piece of aluminum foil.  
  3. Reheat the wings for 10 minutes and check the internal temperature for 165 degrees Fahrenheit.  
  4. Enjoy! 

How to Reheat Buffalo Wild Wings in a Pan on the Stove 

A frying pan might actually be the best way to reheat your wings for many reasons.  

How To Reheat Buffalo Wild Wings in a Pan on the Stove

It’s fast. It’s easy. And it locks in moisture.  

Use these easy steps to get great-tasting wings on the stovetop: 

  1. Allow your Buffalo Wild Wings to sit on the counter for a few minutes and come to room temperature. 
  2. Heat a frying pan on the stove to medium-high heat and add a layer of oil to the bottom of the pan for frying.  
  3. Place your wings in the pan and cook for 3-4 minutes on one side. Flip the wings to the other side and cook another 4 minutes.  
  4. Check your internal temperature for 165 degrees Fahrenheit, serve, and enjoy! 

WINNER – The Best Way to Reheat Buffalo Wild Wings Is Using the Stovetop 

The stovetop is the winner for Buffalo Wild Wings.  

While the oven and the air fryer will get the job done, and done well, the stovetop will give you that fried, crispy effect you can’t get anywhere else.  

What are your best methods for reheating Buffalo Wild Wings? Do you have any tips for reheating Buffalo Wild Wings? Let me know in the comments below. I love to hear from my readers. 

Leave a Comment